XO's
CORNER :
FEQUENTLY
ASKED QUESTIONS RELATING TO GETTING STARTED WITH
THE 5TH RANGER INFANTRY BATTALION
|
How
do blank rounds in the M1 Garand work?
Blanks
and blank firing adapters, also known as BFA's are used
in conjunction with WWII era small arms. This is to say
that you are adapting a live firearm to function with
blank ammunition as if it were firing live rounds. No
projectile ever leaves the barrel. We do not use airsoft,
bb guns, cap guns, dummy replicas, nerf guns or bottle
rockets whatsoever. The M1 Garand, a primary small arm
used in WWII and in reenacting is one of the easiest weapons
to blank adapt. This is done with a simple screw on BFA
that can be easily applied/removed with a typical M3A1
combo tool or screwdriver. They screw onto the end of
the muzzle and lock in place using the gas screw. They
are not permanent nor do they affect the function of the
weapon once removed. They can be found at gun shows and
at gun parts suppliers such as SARCO
and NORTHRIDGE
INC.
Another
type of BFA for the M1 Garand is the "Hollywood"
blank adapter or "one piece" adapter. These
are currently available from GUIETTE
MFG. (at the very bottom of the page). These are the
best BFA’s for the M1 Garand and also the safest.
They can also be found from time to time on E-Bay.
How
do blanks in the M1 Carbine work?
Blank
adapting the M1 Carbine is a more intense and somewhat
permanent process. It requires the barrel to be tapped.
Tapping a barrel means drilling threads into the muzzle
to accept an internal BFA. This is a permanent modification
to the barrel. The process of tapping an M1 Carbine is
however the most effective way to blank adapt your M1
Carbine for use at events.
First
off, your selection of a weapon to adapt is important.
Nearly any barrel can be tapped and fitted for blank operation.
An extensive "how-to" detailing the process
can be found here.
This should be done by a competent gunsmith with some
milling experience.
This
modification to the barrel and will effect accuracy when
shooting live ammo, especially when fired at distant targets.
However, given the effective range of the carbine, target
shooting with the weapon and effects on its accuracy should
be of little worry. The major concern over this is weather
or not you want to "ruin" an original WWII or
Korean War era barrel by tapping it. It will degrade the
resale value of an original; but can actually BOOST the
value if resold to another re-enactor to use for the same
purpose. This is why I recommend leaving your Underwood,
Inland, Winchester, etc. Carbine in the wall locker and
getting a post war manufacture Plainfield M1 Carbine.
By
tapping a postwar Carbine, you are saving money, and not
degrading the value of an original weapon. Avoid the postwar
Universal and IMI carbines, as they are unreliable (by
my experience) and do not accept GI parts as easily as
the Plainfield (in some cases). Bear in mind that in purchasing
a Plainfield post-war M1 Carbine you will have to replace
some of the parts to bring it back into WWII configuration.
Most of the WWII era carbines were also refitted after
the war with the new series of parts. To get a Carbine
back into its M1 WWII configuration; some parts changes
and modifications may include:
Replacing
the M2 round bolt with an M1 flat bolt.
Replacing
the adjustable ramp rear sight with the Type 1 flip or;
also known as "L" sight.
Replacing
an M2 "Potbelly" or postwar civilian stock with
a WWII "Hi-wood" stock.
Replacing
the 4-rivet hand guard with 2-rivet. Match the wood finish
to that of the stock if possible should you end up with
stock that doesn't include the hand guard.
Replacing
the Type 2 or Type 3 barrel band (the Type 3 features
the bayonet lug) with a Type 1 barrel band. This will
require the removal of the front sight aperture.
You
may wish to replace the post war style flip safety lever
with the WWII style push button safety. This is not a
difficult process but the difference is indistinguishable
at more than a few yards away and the flip safety is said
to be more reliable. Either one is acceptable.
Sources
for the parts can readily be found online at the following
parts suppliers or at militaria and gun shows such as
the Knob Creek MG Shoot, OVMS Show of Shows, and National
Gun Day. Online suppliers include Sarco
Inc. E-Gunparts
Northridge Inc.
and E-Bay.
Where
do I get blank ammunition?
Most
WWII small arms function with few or no problems using
blank ammunition. Crimped blanks do not send any projectile
along the lines of a bullet out of the muzzle but are
still dangerous at very close range. Special care should
still be taken and safety regulations followed when using
blank ammo. Treat every weapon as if it were loaded.
There
are several places to purchase blank ammunition including
WW2 Blanks and
Joe Swanson Motion
Picture Blanks (recommended). Joe Swanson has the
best blanks out there, and prices that can’t be
beat for the high quality they offer. Orders may be placed
via US mail. By ordering more ammo at once, rather than
100 or 200 rounds at a time, shipping is cheaper. Generally,
depending your combat behavior and more importantly the
type of event, a new recruit may go thru roughly 100 rounds
of .30-06 blanks running an M1 Garand per event. Some
events might only see you fire 3 or 4 clips; others, 3
or 4 bandoleers. Again, this is a rough estimate that
depends on your combat behavior and the type of event.
However, you can never have too much ammo. You do not
want to run out.
What
type of M1 Helmet should I use and where do I get one?
You
have a few options for helmets, you can use an original,
a postwar, or a refurbished M1 helmet that may contain
a mix of original, postwar, or reproduction components.
There are a number of suppliers for helmets, including
J. Murray, Inc.
ATF (At
the Front) and Top
Pots. You can also find them (typically the steel
pots) at surplus stores and fit them with liners, chin
straps, and paint jobs of your choice. Either fixed or
swivel bail pots are acceptable. A "bail" refers
to the type of attachment of the chin strap to the steel
shell.
Olive
Drab #7 green paint jobs with cork or sand finish are
preferred. You will find that there are multiple color
configurations for WWII helmets, so if the shade paint
on your helmet doesn't exactly match one in a photo, don't
worry about it.
The
5th Ranger diamond will be painted on the back of your
helmet at your first event whenever possible for free,
and is highly recommended You DO NOT need to include the
decal on your helmet if you order from a supplier that
provides them. If you would prefer to paint your own helmet
diamond, contact your company CO for the type, color,
and dimensions of the 5th Ranger Battalion diamond and
rank bar (if applicable) markings. Other "custom"
helmet markings may be allowed but you should consult
your squad leader or CO first.
Where
do I find field uniforms?
The
5th Rangers wore the Wool M1937 and latter pattern uniforms
almost exclusively over any other type. While the 2nd
Ranger Battlion wore HBT trousers and fatigues on D-Day
the 5th Rangers wore wools. However; HBT trousers or M1943
Standard (un-modified) trousers are acceptable for some
tactical events under certain conditions.
Uniforms
are available from a number of vendors, and may be both
original and/or reproduction manufacture. Original wools
are still around and not terribly expensive. There are
many manufacturers and dealers that cater to the WWII
reenacting community and finding pieces for your basic
impression should not be a problem. Here is a very short
list of WWII uniform and equipment vendors:
WWII
Impressions - High cost; high quality reproduction
US uniforms and gear.
At the Front - Reproduction
uniforms and gear with a decent price/quality ratio.
What Price Glory
- Great equipment source; with some good finds on uniforms.
Bayonet Inc. Reasonable
prices on reproduction U.S. web gear of decent quality.
1940
Dog Tag Chains - Alex Solera's repro early war dog
tag chains.
Paul Nason Dog
Tags- Repro notched dog tags.
E-Bay
Original and Reproduction items sold at auction. Beware
of fakes and high-balls.
For
a more substancial list on our site, click here.
What
are HBT's
and what do they have to do with Rangers?
HBT or "Herring Bone Twill" (referring to the
type of material used) are a lightweight series of field
fatigues that were not heavily used by the 5th Rangers
in combat. They are the historically correct garment for
the 2nd Rangers on D-Day and dry much faster than wools.
However, Wools are required for D-Day public events and
are the standard combat uniform of the 5th Rangers thru
the majority of the war. Original WWII wools are still
available for decent prices. You can still find them much
cheaper than reproductions at military shows and on E-Bay
from time to time.
The
specifics on wool trousers are: Trousers, Field, Wool,
M1937 and are mustard green/brown in color.
HBTs,
being cooler and lighter than wools are allowed at tactical
events, and can be used in conjunction with a wool M1937
or M1942 shirt and field jacket of some type. The typical
field jacket of the 5th Rangers was the M1941 Field Jacket.
It can be worn overtop of HTB and/or wool field uniforms.
What
about dress uniforms?
These
are considered a "2nd level" impression item
that is not required for your first event but something
you will need for other events that will extend beyond
the battlefield. Many times we will hit local diners or
eat out with other re-enactors in "Class A"
dress. Again, this is a uniform where originals or reproductions
are acceptable. You can get repro "Ike" Jackets
from some of the vendors above, or get an original in
your size possibly. The Ike Jacket is the prefered Class
A uniform jacket for your Class A dress. Setup your impression
around your Ike Jacket as that of a VE-Day timeframe.
Rank, ribbons, and badges are awarded based on the criteria
in the TO&E (Table of Organization and Equipment)
which is available to all new recruits.
What
is the TO&E, or Table of Organization and Equipment?
This
is a set of rules and regulations outlining the basic
setup of the organization, its procedures, rank structure,
uniform and equipment guidelines and tons of other general
information, described in depth. It is available to any
new member upon filling out a membership application or
to anyone interested in joining the unit; by request.
New members will get their e-copy of the TO&E and
continue to get updates to it so long as they are on the
unit roster. A hard copy is available by mail if so desired.
To request a copy of the document OUTSIDE of submitting
a membership application, please send a request, including
the reason for requesting a copy if you are not a potential
member, via e-mail here.
What
happens my first time in the field?
For
a new member's first event with the Battalion, it is important
to prepare yourself before hand as much as possible. Read
over the basic Infantry Field Manual (FM 21 100) if you
have one available and familiarize yourself with hand
signals, rank, and the tips listed here
as best you can. The veteran members will take care of
you at your first event and give you a few events to get
accustomed to "combat" and how it all works
if you are entirely new to the hobby. You're own pace
of participation and learning will determine you involvement
at the squad level.
The
following sites are a BIG help to new members, and we
recommend you familiarize yourself with some of their
content:
Hard
Scrabble Farm WWII
Strictly
G.I.
You
should be adept with the function and use of your primary
arm before your first event as a rifleman. Spend some
time at the range firing in different positions and practice
loading your weapon, clearing jams, cleaning it, etc.
before you get in the field. If you do not have a weapon
for your first event one may be provided for you. The
function and features of the weapon will be demonstrated
to you prior to using it. For you to keep pace with the
squad you must be combat effective and know how to operate
your weapon on your own.
Do
I need prior training?
No
professional training is required before your first event.
Its recommended that you have as much of your basic kit
as possible along with a weapon; a general knowledge of
WWII, specifically the ETO and US Army Rangers in WWII,
and your jump boots. Hand signals and rank can be picked
up from reading (see above) along with some of the other
skills.
This
hobby can be physically demanding. You need to be in good
enough shape to pack a 10lb rifle and around 30lbs or
more of gear and ammo for 3 to 8 hours in your uniform
and jump boots. over uneven terrain in varying weather
conditions. You need to be able to sprint distances of
10 to 100 yards in your full kit without stopping.
What
are the "Rules of Engagement"?
The
battle rules and regulations differ per event and event
organizers. Overall, safety regulations included not shooting
directly at someone within 25 feet (point you weapon well
above and to the left or right of them) Keep your safety
on until told to click off or "go hot" and practice
safe firearms handling. Do NOT load your weapon until
you are told to do so. If you have a question or problem,
ask an officer or NCO. Take care of your weapon and your
gear; they will take care of you. Other more specific
rules and regulations that pertain to that specific event
will be explained prior to going into the field.
What
are the costs of this hobby?
The
total cost for WWII Ranger impression depends on your
MOS (your type of impression) and where you purchase your
items from. Some impressions include medic, rifleman,
machine gunner, ammo bearer, assistant gunner, radio operator,
company clerk, AT gunner, and so on. For your basic kit
(your required basic uniform and equipment items for a
5th Ranger from D-Day on) you will spend around $400 not
including boots and a weapon. Again, depending on where
you buy items and how much of a bargain hunter you are,
this can go up and down. Period specific impressions such
as D-Day impressions and winter combat items will require
additional cost. There is no limit as to how much you
want to put into an impression.
There
are significant travel costs to the hobby. While we do
carpool to many events, you may need to drive yourself
to some of them at some point. Not all events are an hour
away. Anything within a 6 hour drive from your location
should be considered a possible event.
Blank
ammunition is a constant cost per events where you will
be firing your weapon. Buying it in bulk saves shipping
and you should not always count on vendors or other re-enactors
having ammo at an event for sale.
One
of the biggest costs in the hobby is committing time to
the unit. It will take a significant amount of time researching,
acquiring, assembling, and physically attending events
to get it right and do justice to the unit you are representing.
Above all else we should remember the veterans we are
trying to honor and the public we are trying to educate
about the actions and sacrifices made not so long ago
by so many brave individuals. The more you put into it,
the more you'll get out. Members will be kept in the flow
of information and online resources are at your disposal.
YOU DECIDE YOUR OWN LEVEL OF INVOLVMENT IN THE UNIT.
Who
is the enemy?
There
is a Axis side to reenacting. Almost every branch of the
armed forces of most nations that were involved in WWII
have a reenactment equivalent. From US Paratroopers, Air
Crews, and Armored Divisions to Russians, German SS, paratroops,
and Heer forces, to Polish forces, British troops, and
even a few French resistance fighters. The primary opponent
is the German re-enactor SS, Heer, and German paratroops
(FJ) are the main opponents at many events. Some of them
speak German and it is recommended you learn some basics
in the language. For the most part, they are not actual
Germans. They are fellow re-enactors, many of which have
Allied impressions also. Keep in mind, German re-enactors
portray individuals fighting for their country just as
we portray individuals fighting for ours. They are not
Nazis or National Socialists and none of us condone that
idealology or their practices.
Can
I have another impression?
Members
of the 5th Ranger Infantry Battalion Re-enacting Society
Inc. can take on as many impressions as they like AS INDIVIDUALS.
They may also be members of other organizations. However;
as a member of the 5th Rangers; your pirmary impression
when re-enacting at events in the company of your fellow
members must be that of a 5th Ranger. Specail cases will
be handled on an individual basis by the Battalion C.O.
Its highly preffered that you make the 5th R.I.B. Inc.
your home organization.
Whats
the story on CAI M1 Garand receivers and rifles?
The
CAI (and Lithgow) receiver is not a “bad”
receiver. However, some have failed, formed cracks, or
had problems with GI parts fitted to them and there are
a handful of “recall” type warnings; such
as on the Fulton
Armory website. This led to the view that there are “bad”
CAI receivers on the market. Whether that "bad"
relates to safety, to functioning, or to reliability varies
depending on the weapon.
Compounding the problem is the average shooter or armature
gunsmith doesn't have the knowledge, gauges, or expertise
to know "good" from "bad”.
For starters, the CAI M1 Garand receivers by design and
critical part dimensions were based on the receiver being
made from a hammer forged piece of steel. The CAI receiver
is made from a casting. To get the same strength from
a casting as from a forging, dimensions either have to
be changed (i.e. increased) or the level of strength reduced.
Since many of the dimensions are critical to reliable
functioning and cannot be changed, the level of safety
in a cast receiver is less than that of a forged receiver.
Fortunately, the level of safety in the M1 design is so
inherently high any reduction is still likely be well
above any minimum needed for normal use and service life.
Secondly, the M1 receiver was designed to be made with
1930's machine tools and techniques. The time, labor,
skill, and tooling costs necessary to make an M1 receiver
that way today would be cost prohibitive. Critical angles,
curves, and dimensions are difficult to duplicate with
today's techniques. CAI didn't always get them right.
Regarding the information at Fulton Armory, every reputable
M1 armorer, refuses to build on CAI receivers. Sometimes
it's for safety reasons; sometimes it's for other dimensional
errors. Regardless, experience has taught them all it's
just not worth the hassle.
If you have a CAI receiver M1 rifle and you’ve had
no problems with it, don’t consider yourself lucky.
Most of them work fine. Some are OK; some aren't. Some
aren't perfect but their imperfections would never be
noticed unless inspected by a competent armorer with an
in-depth knowledge of the M1 design.
Bottom line, they are not, never have been, and never
will be the equal of a USGI receiver.
Whats
an ASN?
ASN
stands for "Army Serial Number". This is your
ID number that appears on your dogtags and other ID papers.
The first two numbers of the ASN for enlisted men reflect
the area of induction of the soldier. For an automatic
ASN generator, go here: http://www.hardscrabblefarm.com/ww2/
For more information on dogtags, vist the "Strictly
GI" website here: http://users.skynet.be/jeeper/page82.html
Special
thanks to Jerry Styles, Tim & Lisa Torey, West
Robeson, and Tom Frost for their contributions contained
within this website. |
|
|
RANGERS
LEAD THE WAY! |
|